Donor Stewardship: Nurture Relationships & Grow Donations

What is donor stewardship? Learn the definition, fundamental principles, and best practices so you could nurture donor relationships and grow donations.

Jackie Plaza

8 minute read

what is Donor Stewardship: strategy, plan, tips and best practices
Trusted by top companies:
client logo: meta
client logo: RTL
client logo: Yotpo
client logo: NetApp
client logo:
client logo: deliverlight

Short answer

What is donor stewardship?

Donor stewardship refers to the process of maintaining and enhancing relationships with donors to ensure their continued support. It's significant as it helps nonprofits retain donors, increase donations, and ultimately, achieve their mission.

The journey of donor stewardship is just as important as the destination

The journey of donor stewardship in nonprofits and charity fundraising is long. It requires you to nurture long-term meaningful relationships with your donors and slowly but surely see them flourish, day by day, year by year.

It's like watching a seed you've planted sprout and grow into a beautiful tree. Each conversation, each thank-you note, and each update is a drop of water nurturing that relationship.

This blog post will provide you with a comprehensive understanding of donor stewardship.

We’ll cover the definition of donor stewardship and the basic operational concepts along with actionable, insightful, and practical best practices and tips.

Ready to roll up your sleeves? Let's get started!

What is the importance of donor stewardship?

Donor stewardship is vital as it nurtures enduring relationships with donors, boosts their satisfaction, and motivates ongoing support for an organization's mission. It's a strategic approach to ensure donors feel valued and remain engaged.

Imagine you're at a party. Would you rather chat with the host who makes you feel welcome or the one who barely acknowledges your presence?

Donor stewardship is the friendly host, ensuring donors stick around for the long haul. It's about making donors feel valued and appreciated, which in turn fosters loyalty.

What is the role of stewardship in donor retention and loyalty?

Stewardship plays a key role in donor retention and loyalty by ensuring donors feel appreciated and connected to the organization. Effective stewardship practices can lead to donors becoming long-term supporters and advocates for the cause.

Donor stewardship is the secret sauce to an organization's success. It's like the foundation of a house; without it, everything else falls apart.

\By nurturing relationships with donors, you're not just securing funds for today, but also ensuring continued support for the future.

The donor stewardship cycle

The donor stewardship cycle is a continuous process that includes identifying potential donors, cultivating relationships, soliciting donations, acknowledging gifts, and nurturing ongoing relationships. It's a strategic approach to donor management.

4 key stages of the donor stewardship cycle:

  1. Cultivation - involves identifying and getting to know potential donors.
  2. Solicitation - the act of asking for support
  3. Acknowledgment - the immediate response after receiving a donation
  4. Relationship-Building - the ongoing communication that keeps donors engaged

Each stage of the donor stewardship cycle is like a step in a dance. Miss one, and you risk tripping up. But get it right, and it's a beautiful performance.

Delivering in each stage of the donor stewardship cycle

The framework for donor engagement involves strategies and activities designed to engage donors at various stages of their relationship with the organization.

It includes personalized communication, meaningful recognition, and opportunities for active involvement.

The framework for engagement is like a roadmap guiding you on your journey of donor stewardship. It's the GPS that keeps you on track.

Each stage of the donor stewardship cycle is like a step in a dance. Miss one, and you risk tripping up. But get it right, and it's a beautiful performance.

Developing a donor stewardship strategy

Creating a nonprofit donor stewardship strategy is like planning a trip. You wouldn't set off without knowing your destination, would you?

An example of a donor stewardship strategy could be a nonprofit organization implementing a personalized communication plan.

This plan could include sending tailored updates to donors about projects they've funded, inviting them to exclusive events, and recognizing their contributions in annual reports or on the organization's website.

Setting goals and objectives

Setting goals and objectives is like marking your destination on a map. It gives you a clear direction and helps you stay on track. These goals could include increasing donor retention rates, improving donor satisfaction, or raising a certain amount of funds.

Common donor stewardship goals:

  1. Donor Retention: Keeping existing donors engaged and continuing their support.
  2. Donor Upgrade: Encouraging donors to increase their level of giving over time.
  3. Donor Satisfaction: Ensuring donors feel valued and satisfied with their involvement in the organization.
  4. Donor Engagement: Increasing donor participation in events, volunteering, or other activities.
  5. Donor Advocacy: Inspiring donors to become advocates for the organization, spreading the word, and attracting new donors.

How to align stewardship objectives with organizational mission and values

Aligning your stewardship objectives with your organization's mission and values ensures you're equipped to reach your destination. This means your stewardship activities should reflect what your organization stands for and aims to achieve.

Crafting a comprehensive stewardship plan

A comprehensive stewardship plan is like a detailed itinerary for your trip. It outlines where you're going, how you'll get there, and what you'll do along the way.

9 components of a robust stewardship plan

A robust stewardship plan typically includes the following components:

  1. Communication Plan: A strategy for regular, personalized communication with donors, including updates on projects, impact stories, and opportunities for involvement.

  2. Donor Engagement Activities: Events or activities designed to engage donors and deepen their connection to your organization.

  3. Donor Feedback Mechanisms: Methods for collecting and incorporating donor feedback to improve your stewardship practices.

  4. Donor Recognition Strategy: A plan for how you will acknowledge and appreciate your donors' contributions.

  5. Donor Retention Strategies: Tactics to keep donors engaged and encourage their continued support.

  6. Donor Upgrade Strategies: Plans for encouraging donors to increase their level of giving over time and become major donors.

  7. Metrics and Evaluation: Key performance indicators (KPIs) and other metrics to measure the effectiveness of your stewardship efforts.

  8. Staff and Volunteer Training: Training programs to ensure your team understands and can effectively implement your stewardship plan.

  9. Budget: A detailed budget that allocates resources to each component of your stewardship plan.

The need for a well-defined timeline and allocated resources

A well-defined timeline and allocated resources are like your travel budget. It ensures you have enough fuel and time to reach your destination.

This involves setting realistic deadlines for your goals and allocating sufficient resources, such as staff and budget, to your stewardship activities.

8 building blocks of effective donor communication and engagement

Effective communication and engagement are like the conversations you have on your journey. They make the trip enjoyable and memorable.

1) Personalized donor communication:

Personalized donor communication shows you care and value the relationship. This could involve tailoring your communication to each donor's interests and preferences, such as sending personalized emails or acknowledging their birthdays.

2) Expressing gratitude and appreciation:

Expressing gratitude and appreciation is like sending postcards during your trip. It's a small gesture that shows you're thinking of them.

This could be as simple as sending a thank-you note after receiving a donation or as elaborate as organizing a donor appreciation event.

3) Sharing impact stories and outcome:

Sharing impact stories is like sharing photos from your trip. It gives them a glimpse into your journey and the difference their support is making.

This could involve sharing success stories from your projects or showing how their donations have been used.

4) Provide regular updates:

Regular updates keep donor in the loop and make them feel part of your journey. This could involve sending regular newsletters, posting updates on your website, or sharing news on social media.

5) Recognition and acknowledgment:

Examples of donor recognition and acknowledgment include:

  • sending personalized thank-you letters
  • mentioning donors in newsletters or annual reports
  • creating a donor wall in your office
  • naming a project or scholarship after a major donor
  • hosting appreciation events
  • and giving commemorative gifts or certificates.

6) Timely and accurate acknowledgment:

Timely and accurate acknowledgment is like thanking your friend for a gift right away. It shows you appreciate their gesture and don't take it for granted.

This could involve sending a receipt immediately after receiving a donation or acknowledging their support in your annual report.

7) Publicly honoring major donors:

This is a public display of appreciation that shows you value their contribution. This could involve featuring them in your newsletter, acknowledging them at an event, or naming a project after them.

8) Personal tokens of appreciation:

Tokens of appreciation show you've put thought into showing your appreciation. This could involve sending a personalized thank-you note, giving a small gift, or offering a unique experience related to your cause.

How to build strong donor relationships

Building strong donor relationships involves regular, personalized communication, and recognition of contributions.

It relies on an experienced staff and a predictable system for meaningful interactions between staff and donors.

Recruit a dedicated donor relations staff:

A dedicated staff is like your organization's ambassadors. They're the face of your organization and play a crucial role in building relationships with donors.

They could be responsible for managing donor communications, organizing donor events, or providing personalized support to major donors.

Set time for one-on-one meetings and donor visits:

One-on-one meetings and donor visits provide an opportunity to deepen the relationship and show you value their support.

This could involve inviting them to visit your projects, meeting them for a meal, or simply calling them to catch up.

Organize donor appreciation events:

Appreciation events are a fun way to show your appreciation and celebrate your shared achievements. This could involve hosting an annual gala, organizing a thank-you luncheon, or inviting donors to a special performance.

Give donors exclusive benefits and privileges:

Exclusive benefits and privileges provide a select group of major donors special access and show you value their support.

This could involve giving them early access to tickets, providing insider updates, or offering unique experiences related to your cause.

Influence of effective stewardship on your fundraising

Effective stewardship can have a significant influence on fundraising. it makes the donor lifecycle smoother and more enjoyable, leading to better outcomes.

There's a strong correlation between successful stewardship and increased support. This may simply be because when donors feel valued and engaged, they're more likely to continue supporting your cause.

How to measure the success of your donor stewardship

There are multiple aspects of your donor stewardship that you need to keep track of and multiple ways for you to do so.

Staying on top of your game and knowing in real time how you're performing requires a rigorous and mindful setup of different tracking measures.

  1. Establish donor stewardship Metrics and KPIs
  2. Track Donor Retention and Giving Patterns
  3. Monitor Donor Feedback and Satisfaction
  4. Conduct Donor Satisfaction Surveys
  5. Collect Feedback on Donor Experiences
  6. Assess the Impact on Fundraising Outcomes
  7. Track donor stewardship content performance

How to create outstanding donor stewardship content

Donors are usually busy people. and as such you need to work to deserve their attention. creating content deserving of donors' attention is a fundamental challenge all nonprofits struggle with.

It used to be that creating Quality content like impact reports, annual reports, and other forms of donor communication was a real headache.

Even if writing the content was a breeze, you'd still have to pay an agency many thousands of dollars to design the content. And delivery time could take months.

But technology has reached a point where it's now simpler, faster, and less costly to create highly engaging interactive content in-house than outsourcing this responsibility to a design agency.

All you need now is a tool like Storydoc that gives you tried and tested content templates Guided by AI insights and real-world feedback.

Pair this with out-of-the-box analytics that gives you insight into how donors read and engaged with your content and you’re set up to make world-class content.

Grab a template from the options below - see how fast you can transform your old PDFs and PowerPoints into engaging content worth sharing.

No templates found
Jackie Plaza

Hi, I’m Jackie, Creative Marketing Specialist at Storydoc, I write on everything business presentations. I love to research and bring to light critical information that helps marketing, sales, and design teams get better results with their collateral.

Grab a report template

Create your best presentation to date

Try Storydoc interactive presentation maker for 14 days free (keep any presentation you make forever!)